Posted by: rationalpsychic | Wednesday, June 27, 2007

Michael Moore’s “Sicko” is Well Worth Seeing

I went to a sneak preview of “Sicko” at the Lagoon theater in Minneapolis on Saturday night. I had watched “Roger and Me” when it came out on DVD and saw “Bowling for Columbine” just two nights before going to see “Sicko.” I’ve always viewed documentaries as being like good medicine: I’ll take them when necessary, but the taste doesn’t keep me coming back for more.

I do think that Michael Moore serves a purpose as a filmmaker and as someone contributing to public debate. For the first time since I was in college and listening to The Clash, I feel like it’s (maybe) OK to mention “socialism” as a valid form of managing a nation’s resources.

I feel that this view is closer to the center than I ever would have thought before. Yesterday on the internet I caught an outdoor segment of Chris Matthews’ “Hardball” in which he was talking to Ann Coulter. She was surrounded by about fifty of her fans on this outdoor set. Let me ask you, if Rush Limbaugh’s fans are called “dittoheads” are Ann Coulter’s fans called “sawdust skulls”?

The reason I bring her up is that she mentioned FDR as having been good on foreign policy for “crushing the Nazi war machine” but had been terrible on domestic policy. Why? Because he had saddled us with socialist ideals which she said we are still struggling to get rid of. I wonder what she’s referring to: Social Security or the minimum wage?

In “Sicko” Moore takes a smart tack in that he doesn’t say that we are in terrible shape because of the number of people in the U.S. who do not have medical insurance. That could lead a lot of us to think to ourselves, “Hey, I step over the homeless every day on my way to work, what does this have to do with me?”

Instead, he asks the rest of us who do have health insurance, “What do you really have and what is it costing you?” And the point it, once you factor in deductibles, co-pays and the fact that you are unsteady ground any time you have something that needs really serious treatment, you’re left wondering why more of us aren’t bankrupt over medical bills and why we aren’t carrying signs in the street?

Moore gives us lots of reasons why we should look to other nations for an example of what can be done well and use the best from each. He examines the Canadians, the British, and the French as examples. From what I can find on the internet, the United Kingdom charges rates from 10-40% (those making over $4,460, between $4,461 and $69,200, and above $69,201) and has a number of deductions allowable. France appears to go from 10-48% while Canada levies from 7-29%. VAT taxes also apply which are considerably higher than most state sales tax rates. Canada has the lowest VAT at 7%.

Some of the more humorous moments come when Michael Moore is trying to get the Canadians to understand the predicament their southern cousins are in. One Canadian fellow (we’ll call him “Bob”) describes having sawn off four of his fingers with a power saw and shows he has decent use of them after they were reattached in a Canadian hospital. Moore then tells him about an American who cut off his middle and ring fingers and goes to the hospital to have them reattached. Since he has no insurance, he is given a choice of having the middle finger reattached for $60,000 or the ring finger for $12,000. Because he’s so sentimental, the fellow chooses the ring finger. Bob, the Canadian whose every doctor’s bill is paid by the government, has a confused look on his face.

After the movie, I felt somewhat ashamed. Ashamed that I wasn’t in the streets with a bullhorn shouting my anger and demanding better treatment for myself and my neighbors. I’ve never done this before. But the stakes keep getting higher.

Next year’s Republican National Convention is being held in the Twin Cities. In one way or another I plan to be there. It’s a matter of organizing under a political banner I can work for and that my conscience will agree with.



  1. Thanks for the review Barrie. I wish we would have been there and saw it with you two. I do believe that the Evans Family Dynamic has never afforded me much of an opportunity to get to know you as a person other than that’s my brother in law. Hopefully we can find more opportunities to chat in relation to each other as people rather than as members of the same family.

    I remember the guy from West Wing hosting a radio program saying that Medicaire is the most efficient system in the world in terms of percentage of money that paid for administration–4%. Working in a medical(sort of) job, I’m sure you’d say that crazy efficient.

    But you can’t buy into the frame that government health care is socialism. Its NOT. Its part of a mixed economy which we already have. We publicly control things like the airwaves and the road system and veteran’s health, this would just take another industry and nationalize it, like the rest of the world does. Ann Coulter that transvestite would prefer you not to see how she’s framing things by using absurdest, extremist rhetoric. Perhaps the fifty people behind her on MSNBC buy into it(the blond lady behind her hooting I found particularly troublesome), but she has talked you into thinking f FDR as a Socialist. You have to avoid the Right-wing Jedi Mind tricks.

    I am Very MUCH looking forward to next year’s GOP convention. I’ve been trying to get Meg to form the Roseville Young Republicans so she can get on the floor and then… but she hasn’t been into it yet. I want to protest, but it might be a really sad affair. With a President at 25% what can they offer?

    By endorsing Moore you do not have to sing the Internationale, but it might be a way to find other moreheads to relate to. ;-.>

  2. Hi. Stumbled in from the rage at de-conversion. What a laugh riot. Anyway, re: the “Bob” the fingers guy in Canada. That operation was done in London Ontario and so, of course, Moore’s Sicko was all over the media here. Here’s my comment on it at

  3. aah, spammed… The Mike & Mike show at cartoonlife dougsamu,

  4. Thank you for this review…. I still haven’t had the opportunity to see this documentary, but I’ve been dying to, as I am very fond of Michael Moore’s work. Some like to believe this is due to my radical tendencies, but these are the same people that increase my need for a plastic bubble.

    The part about the American citizen who lost two fingers and because he had no insurance was given the choice of picking one… I wonder why the ring finger was more expensive than the middle finger… Hmm… You can’t flip the president off with a ring finger… and that’s priceless!!! :P…

    Ok… I shall get some rest.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s


%d bloggers like this: